AI Hotel Index · Christmas

How AI recommends The Peninsula New York

AI recommended The Peninsula New York in 40% of answers about where to stay in New York for Christmas (6 of 15), #2 of the 40 hotels it named. Most of those recommendations came from one question: where to stay to see the Rockefeller Center tree and holiday windows.

Recommended by 4 of 5 AI platforms · Updated as new AI answers come in · Official website

Share of answers

40%

6 of 15 Christmas answers

Rank

#2

of 40 hotels AI named

Listed first

2

answers with it as the top pick

Average position

2.8

in lists of about 5 hotels

Recommended by

4 of 5

AI platforms · most often Gemini

By AI platform

Gemini named it most. Muse did not name it in any Christmas answer.

ChatGPT: recommended in 1 of 3 answers
ChatGPT
33% (1/3)
Claude: recommended in 1 of 3 answers
Claude
33% (1/3)
Gemini: recommended in 2 of 3 answers
Gemini
67% (2/3)
Meta AI: recommended in 2 of 3 answers
Meta AI
67% (2/3)
Muse: recommended in 0 of 3 answers
Muse
0% (0/3)

By traveler need

Named most for Event trip. Not named in any of the 5 Budget answers.

Event trip: recommended in 4 of 5 answers
Event trip
80% (4/5)
Families: recommended in 2 of 5 answers
Families
40% (2/5)
Budget: recommended in 0 of 5 answers
Budget
0% (0/5)

Each AI, each traveler

Share of each AI's answers for that traveler type that recommend the hotel. Hover a cell for the count. Darker means recommended more often.

FamiliesBudgetEvent tripChatGPT0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers100%Recommended in 1 of 1 answersClaude0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers100%Recommended in 1 of 1 answersGemini100%Recommended in 1 of 1 answers0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers100%Recommended in 1 of 1 answersMeta AI100%Recommended in 1 of 1 answers0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers100%Recommended in 1 of 1 answersMuse0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers0%Recommended in 0 of 1 answers

The questions travelers asked

Each question is asked to every AI on a regular schedule, in a fresh chat. The count is how many of those answers recommended The Peninsula New York.

Traveler questionNeedRecommended in
Which hotel should I book in New York to see the Rockefeller Center Christmas tree and the holiday windows this year?Event trip4 of 5
We're bringing our kids to New York to see the Christmas lights and the Rockefeller Center tree this year. Which hotel should we book?Families2 of 5
Where should I stay in New York for a Christmas trip this year if I want to walk to the holiday markets and the Rockefeller Center tree but keep it under $300 a night?Budget0 of 5

Recommended alongside

Hotels in the same answers

Named together in 6 of its 6 answers
Lotte New York Palace
6
Named together in 3 of its 6 answers
The Jewel facing Rockefeller Center
3
Named together in 3 of its 6 answers
The Plaza
3
Named together in 2 of its 6 answers
Omni Berkshire Place
2
Named together in 2 of its 6 answers
Waldorf Astoria New York
2
Named together in 1 of its 6 answers
Andaz 5th Avenue
1

Most recommended for Christmas

Share of all 15 answers

#2The Peninsula New York40%

Where AI gets its information

The hotel's own site was cited in 0 Christmas answers. 9 of the 15 answers listed their sources.

In answers that recommended The Peninsula New York

bloggeratlarge.comTravel guide1
chainstoreage.comTravel guide1
hotelierschoice.comTravel guide1
instagram.comTravel guide1
loomavoy.comTravel guide1

Across all Christmas answers

nycinsiderguide.comTravel guide3
bloggeratlarge.comTravel guide2
hotelierschoice.comTravel guide2
travelpirates.comTravel guide2

Is this your hotel?

See how AI decides on The Peninsula New York. Thirty minutes with the founder who runs this research.

Embed this badge

For hotels in the top 10 for Christmas. It links back to this page and updates with the ranking.

#2Recommended by AIChristmas · Nov 2026Arrivl AI Hotel Index<a href="https://arrivl.ai/hotels/new-york/the-peninsula-new-york?utm_source=badge"><img src="https://arrivl.ai/badges/new-york/the-peninsula-new-york.svg" alt="#2 recommended by AI for Christmas · Arrivl AI Hotel Index" width="320" height="96"></a>

FAQ

Does ChatGPT recommend The Peninsula New York?

Yes. ChatGPT recommended The Peninsula New York in 1 of its 3 answers about where to stay in New York for Christmas (33%).

Which AI recommends The Peninsula New York most?

Gemini, in 2 of 3 answers about where to stay in New York for Christmas (67%). Meta AI named it in 2 of 3, ChatGPT named it in 1 of 3, Claude named it in 1 of 3.

Which hotels does AI recommend instead for Christmas?

Lotte New York Palace (53% of answers), The Jewel facing Rockefeller Center (40%) and Omni Berkshire Place (33%) were named most often.

For which trips does AI suggest The Peninsula New York?

Most often for Event trip: 4 of its 6 recommendations.

Which websites does AI use when it recommends The Peninsula New York?

rockefellercenter.com, bloggeratlarge.com, chainstoreage.com and hotelierschoice.com were cited most often in those answers. Those answers did not cite the hotel's own website.

Methodology

The same traveler questions go to each AI on a fixed schedule, each in a fresh chat that ignores saved memories and searches the web as it normally would. A hotel counts once per answer when the AI recommends it; hotels it mentions only to rule out are left out. Change compares the period with the one before it; all time compares the more recent half of the runs with the earlier half. A recommendation shows what the AI said; it is not a rating of the hotel.